How your customer asks decides who gets named
Most people check their AI visibility with one question. Usually the one they'd type into Google.
That's one way of asking. Your customers use others.
In October I asked ChatGPT, Gemini, Claude and Grok three questions for ten trades in Amsterdam, Utrecht and Haarlem. All in Dutch, web search on. The three questions were written to sound like three different people:
- a short search, like "dentist Amsterdam new patients"
- a long, specific one: I just moved here, I want good reviews, a calm approach, who do you recommend?
- an advice question: what should I look for, and who does that well?
Same trade. Same city. Same four AIs. Only the wording changed.
The number
Across the 30 pages, the AIs named 909 businesses.
146 of them came up for all three questions. About one in six.
557 came up for only one of the three.
So for most businesses that got named, it depended on how the customer asked.
Dentists in Amsterdam
48 practices named. Only two came up for all three questions: TandartsJordaan and Tandartspraktijk Jan van Galen.
The short search turned up 25 different practices. The long, specific question turned up 14.
That pattern held overall. The long questions, the ones with real wishes in them, got fewer names than the short searches. 409 against 497, counted across all pages. When a customer says what they want, the AI gets pickier.
What it means for you
A long, specific question sounds like someone who's ready to book. Those questions had fewer names to go around.
To get named there, the AI needs to know more than your name and your street. It needs the details that customer is asking about: do you take new patients, do you fit kitchens with your own team, what are you known for. Written down clearly, on your own site and elsewhere.
If you only show up for the short search, you're visible to people browsing. Not yet to people deciding.
Check yours
The free scan at foreground.info asks the AIs the questions your customers ask, and shows where you come up.
Ask it the way they ask it.